Research suggests vocational GCSEs may be holding girls back

Girls who take ‘applied’ subjects, such as health and social care or home economics, at GCSE may be facing educational disadvantage as a result, a new study has found.

The researchers, from the Centre for Longitudinal Studies at the UCL Institute of Education, used data from Next Steps, a study of 16,000 people born in England in 1989-90, and from the National Pupil Database. The research was funded by the Nuffield Foundation and the Economic and Social Research Council.

Young people who took applied GCSEs were less likely to stay on at A-level and to take ‘facilitating’ A-levels favoured by prestigious universities. Vocational subjects appeared to put both boys and girls at a disadvantage, even after taking into account the fact that less privileged young people and those with lower prior Key Stage test scores were more likely to take applied subjects at GCSE.

This disadvantage linked to applied GCSEs was particularly strong for girls. In particular, the researchers found that girls studying applied GCSEs were less likely to take ‘facilitating’ A-levels such as the sciences and maths. These findings suggest that girls could be held back if their schools encourage them to take those options.

Vanessa Moulton, the lead author of the paper, published today by CLS, says applied subjects can be particularly unhelpful for girls who want to progress in education: “Applied subjects are particularly strongly gendered, with girls and boys taking completely different subjects. Essentially what you see is predominantly working class girls taking subjects such as health and social care, which do not necessarily enhance their future prospects,” she said. “Boys are more likely to take subjects such as engineering or information and communication technology, which may be less limiting post-16.”

The research also examined whether pupils had taken ‘EBacc’ subjects for GCSE, and found pupils studying them were more likely to stay in education after 16. This was particularly true for girls.

The findings appear to give some support to Government reforms, which see schools judged on the proportion of pupils gaining good GCSEs in academic subjects, including languages, history or geography (known as the ‘EBacc’). Opponents of the EBacc have argued it leads to too narrow a curriculum, and that these subjects are not always suitable for less able pupils.

Vanessa Moulton said: “We are unable to find evidence to support the value of less academic – non-EBacc – or applied subjects, not just on average, but for any social group, including working class pupils. In fact, for white pupils and girls in particular, taking EBacc subjects was strongly associated with staying on in full time education past 16.”

Meanwhile another paper in the same series, also published today,highlights the influence that schools have on the GCSE subjects that pupils take. Researchers found that the biggest influence on whether or not pupils choose to study academically demanding subjects at GCSE, is the average attainment at their school and not their own past performance. The paper uses data from the National Pupil Database on mainstream English state-funded schools for the academic year 2005-06.

According to the research, a bright pupil in an academically selective school is more likely to take an academic route than an equally bright pupil in a less selective school. Pupils in single-sex schools are also more likely to study academically demanding subjects.

Jake Anders of the UCL Institute of Education, the lead author on the study, said: “These results highlight that we should be sceptical of considering young people’s subjects of study purely in terms of ‘choice.’ They are, at most, constrained choices, potentially both for individuals and for schools.”

Some schools with less advantaged intakes may be more likely to offer their pupils more applied subjects, the paper suggests. Alternatively, schools in poorer areas may struggle to recruit good teachers in more academic subjects, and this may prevent pupils from taking certain combinations of options.

Related


Explore our projects

row of houses
New

Welfare | 2025 - 2028

Musculoskeletal conditions in underserved communities

View project
New

Education | 2025 - 2028

EXAMINE: Exam inequality for neurodivergent students

View project
New

Education | 2025 - 2025

Exploring Multi Academy Trust approaches to Artificial Intelligence

View project
Candid portrait of college students working, blue and orange partitions provide privacy
New

Education | 2025 - 2027

Addressing Undermatch in HE destinations

View project
A female secondary school student, sitting down in a teacher's office in a school. They are having a meeting and the teacher is taking notes while the girl talks.
New

Education | 2025 - 2026

Exclusionary practice in English secondary schools

View project
Elevated view of students sitting and learning in computer room
New

Education | 2025 - 2027

Improving wellbeing-focused online media literacy in schools

View project
Childminder playing with toddler

Education | 2025 - 2027

Examining the challenges and benefits of childminding in England

View project
Female electrician arrives at job. She is wearing an orange hi-vis jacket and behind her is a van.
New

Welfare | 2025 - 2026

Characterising the job ladder in England

View project
New

Education | 2025 - 2026

Pupil wellbeing and increased persistent absenteeism: An investigation

View project
New

Welfare | 2025 - 2027

All women are born (un)equal: menopause, HRT and women’s well-being

View project
traditional detached house within residential estate in England UK, several houses in view have solar panels on the roof.
New

Welfare | 2025 - 2026

Distributional impacts of net zero on electricity consumers

View project
In progress

Education | Welfare | 2025 - 2028

Clear Skies, Clear Minds: Air quality and children’s welfare

View project
New

Education | 2025 - 2028

EXAMINE: Exam inequality for neurodivergent students

View project
New

Education | 2025 - 2025

Exploring Multi Academy Trust approaches to Artificial Intelligence

View project
row of houses
New

Welfare | 2025 - 2028

Musculoskeletal conditions in underserved communities

View project
A female secondary school student, sitting down in a teacher's office in a school. They are having a meeting and the teacher is taking notes while the girl talks.
New

Education | 2025 - 2026

Exclusionary practice in English secondary schools

View project
Candid portrait of college students working, blue and orange partitions provide privacy
New

Education | 2025 - 2027

Addressing Undermatch in HE destinations

View project
New

Education | 2025 - 2026

Pupil wellbeing and increased persistent absenteeism: An investigation

View project
traditional detached house within residential estate in England UK, several houses in view have solar panels on the roof.
New

Welfare | 2025 - 2026

Distributional impacts of net zero on electricity consumers

View project
Portrait of a senior woman at home checking a letter in the mail
New

Welfare | 2025 - 2026

How can low earners afford a commensurate retirement income?

View project
Female electrician arrives at job. She is wearing an orange hi-vis jacket and behind her is a van.
New

Welfare | 2025 - 2026

Characterising the job ladder in England

View project
In progress

Education | 2023 - 2025

Interventions supporting early self-regulation: a systematic literature review

View project
New

Education | 2025

Implementing effective early education interventions at scale

View project
Shop assistant in supermarket re-stocking fresh vegetables in shelves of produce section.
New

Education | 2025 - 2026

Youth transitions to good employment: East Birmingham & North Solihull

View project
In progress

Education | 2023 - 2025

Interventions supporting early self-regulation: a systematic literature review

View project
In progress

Education | Welfare | 2025 - 2028

Clear Skies, Clear Minds: Air quality and children’s welfare

View project
In progress

Education | 2024 - 2026

Beyond teacher assessed grades: Post-16 education choices and COVID-19

View project
Group of students sit around a table listening.
In progress

Education | 2024 - 2026

Educational dialogue for improving Foundation Year student outcomes

View project
In progress

Education | Justice | 2024 - 2027

Evaluating the Fundamental British Values initiative of the DfE

View project
In progress

Welfare | 2024 - 2028

Well-being in later life in Bradford 

View project
Happy woman talking to a colleague at work
In progress

Education | Welfare | 2024 - 2026

Employer investment in upskilling and reskilling in a changing economy

View project
A boy, wearing his PE kit, leans against the lockers. He's on his own in a corridor at school and is looking at the camera.
In progress

Education | 2024 - 2027

Out of sight: exclusions, alternative provision and later life outcomes 

View project
Nursery child playing with teacher in the classroom
In progress

Education | 2024 - 2027

Achieving high-quality provision in the baby room of English nurseries

View project
A front view of a father and his two children. He is carrying his young son in his arms and his daughter is riding her scooter along the footpath as he pushes his son's scooter along the way.
In progress

Justice | Welfare | 2024 - 2026

Challenging justice inequalities with children in conflict with the law 

View project
In progress

Education | 2024 - 2026

Can digital parenting interventions benefit early language development?

View project
three women walking along street laughing and smiling
In progress

Welfare | 2023 - 2025

Revealing social capital

View project
New

Education | 2025 - 2028

EXAMINE: Exam inequality for neurodivergent students

View project
New

Education | 2025 - 2025

Exploring Multi Academy Trust approaches to Artificial Intelligence

View project
row of houses
New

Welfare | 2025 - 2028

Musculoskeletal conditions in underserved communities

View project
Candid portrait of college students working, blue and orange partitions provide privacy
New

Education | 2025 - 2027

Addressing Undermatch in HE destinations

View project
New

Education | 2025 - 2026

Pupil wellbeing and increased persistent absenteeism: An investigation

View project
traditional detached house within residential estate in England UK, several houses in view have solar panels on the roof.
New

Welfare | 2025 - 2026

Distributional impacts of net zero on electricity consumers

View project
Portrait of a senior woman at home checking a letter in the mail
New

Welfare | 2025 - 2026

How can low earners afford a commensurate retirement income?

View project
Female electrician arrives at job. She is wearing an orange hi-vis jacket and behind her is a van.
New

Welfare | 2025 - 2026

Characterising the job ladder in England

View project
New

Education | 2025

Implementing effective early education interventions at scale

View project
Shop assistant in supermarket re-stocking fresh vegetables in shelves of produce section.
New

Education | 2025 - 2026

Youth transitions to good employment: East Birmingham & North Solihull

View project
Close up of a Young woman going over her retirement savings at home while using her laptop
New

Welfare | 2025 - 2026

Tackling the information gap in retirement saving decisions

View project
New

Welfare | 2025 - 2027

All women are born (un)equal: menopause, HRT and women’s well-being

View project
Reception class children using a parachute in a PE lesson
Reported

Education | 2022 - 2023

A movement and story-telling intervention for reception children

View project
Reported

Education | Welfare | 2022 - 2024

Understanding school attendance, education and labour market outcomes

View project
A classroom of children with their hands up to answer a question, with two teachers at the front of the classroom
Reported

Education | 2022 - 2024

Inspecting the inspectorate: new insights into Ofsted inspections

View project
Grandparents having fun outdoors with their granddaughter, who is eating an apple and laughing: Understanding family and community vulnerabilities in transition to net zero
Reported

Welfare | 2021 - 2023

Understanding family and community vulnerabilities in transition to net zero

View project
Father and son using laptop at home
Reported

Welfare | 2021 - 2025

Developing a minimum digital living standard for households with children

View project
Code encounters algorithmic risk-profiling in housing: a family in their kitchen at home
Reported

Welfare | 2022 - 2024

Code encounters: algorithmic risk-profiling in housing

View project
Side view of two female high school students in classroom working on laptops social distancing. Student in foreground is in focus and student in background is blurred
Reported

Education | 2021 - 2022

COVID-19 and disadvantage gaps in England 2020 and 2021

View project
Close up of a young girl and her father wearing protective face masks during the COVID-19 pandemic outside.
Reported

Welfare | 2021 - 2023

The Economy 2030 Inquiry: navigating a decade of change

View project
Young boy draws and plays with a globe as part of nursery education
Reported

Education | 2020 - 2022

COVID-19 and childcare: local impacts across England

View project
Reported

Education | 2020 - 2022

Ethical principles underpinning co-production with young people

View project
Reported

Education | 2020 - 2021

COVID-19 mitigation measures: education provision and access to special schools

View project
Young-boy-uses-tablet-with-mother-for-maths-learning-Can-maths-apps-add-value-to-learning-PROJ
Reported

Education | 2020 - 2022

Can maths apps add value to learning?

View project
Search projects

We improve people’s lives by funding research that informs social policy, primarily in Education, Welfare and Justice. We also fund student programmes that give young people skills and confidence in science and research.

We offer our grant-holders the freedom to frame questions and enable new thinking. Our research must stand up to rigorous academic scrutiny, but we understand that to be successful in effecting change, it also needs to be relevant to people’s experience.

Profile