There can be no doubt that the UK faces a serious challenge: too many young people are neither earning nor learning.
Alan Milburn and his team have done an impressive job of putting this issue on the national agenda. Over the 12 months of this government-commissioned Review, they have engaged young people, employers, government and civil society to find ways to confront the challenge head-on.
The final report makes recommendations spanning early education to the world of work. Whether these are adopted in full or in part, the Review will have a lasting impact on the lives of children who have been in care because it recognises that the state needs to be held to account for helping them make the transition into employment.
A persistent gap in opportunity
A staggering 40% of care leavers aged 19–21 are not in education, employment or training (NEET). Young people who have been in the care of the state are three times more likely than their peers to be neither earning nor learning. This gap has not narrowed since national data collection began in 2018.
The Milburn Review recognises the many reasons why care leavers are particularly disadvantaged. They are more likely to have experienced a disrupted education, have special educational needs or disabilities, achieve lower attainment, and experience poor mental health and wellbeing. Many begin living independently at an earlier age. Some face unstable housing, and many have experienced multiple moves. They are also less likely to have a trusted adult to advocate for them. Employers, meanwhile, may assume levels of stability, support and work history that care-experienced young people are less likely to have.
Simply offering care leavers the same support as their peers will not close the gap in their education and employment outcomes.
What the Milburn Review recommends
Significantly, the Review proposes judging Strategic Authorities on whether they are closing the participation gap between care leavers and other young people. Every ‘Area Youth Participation Plan’ will be required to explain how this will be achieved.
The Review also recommends that care-experienced young people are prioritised for early support. The proposed ‘Youth Opportunity Service’ will offer young people an adviser and access to employment, health, disability and wider youth support. For care-experienced young people at risk of becoming disengaged from education or employment, the Review argues this work should begin at 16, rather than waiting until they are 18.
The Review also proposes additional financial support for care leavers, recognising that they cannot turn to the bank of Mum and Dad. It recommends setting the proposed Youth Allowance, which would replace existing benefits, at a higher level for care leavers. Those not in education, employment or training should also be entitled to a ‘Transition Allowance’ of £50 a week for six months, conditional on working with their local Youth Opportunity Service. A similar scheme in Trafford successfully helped more care leavers into work.
To encourage employers to take on care leavers, an additional premium payment of £2,000 will be offered.
What the evidence tells us
Together these recommendations align with emerging evidence on how best to support care-experienced young people into work. A small number of interventions are currently being tested in randomised controlled trials, with promising early findings. They tend to share three features: sustained one-to-one support, a tailored support package, and active help to secure opportunities in education, employment and training.
The measures set out in the Milburn Review are therefore very welcome and have the potential to start to close the gap in the NEET rate between care leavers and the peers for the first time.
Getting into work starts with better care
But we should not assume that helping care-experienced young people into work is solely a matter of supporting the transition from education to employment.
Wider improvements to the support young people receive when they are in, and leaving, care may matter as much as, or even more than, changes to employment support. Tackling the social isolation of young people leaving care and the lack of trusted adults around them is a prerequisite to change.
Around 10,000 children in care are currently living in independent, semi-independent or supported accommodation in England. The law only requires children in care to live under adult supervision and protection until they are 16 and the number of 16- and 17-year-olds legally in the care of the state and living independently or semi-independently has more than doubled in the last decade to at least one in every three.
So the Government must look for changes beyond the careers adviser or jobcentre and ultimately at the quality of ‘care’ in the care system. Entering work is not simply about being helped to become work-ready and finding the right job. Young people also need the basic building blocks of life in place to make the most of those opportunities.
Lisa Harker is Director of Nuffield Family Justice Observatory, one of our expert Centres. Nuffield FJO makes life better for children and families by holding a mirror to the family justice system.













