Only one in ten people with experience of trying to resolve a legal problem trusted the justice system to treat people fairly, according to a major new review commissioned by the Nuffield Foundation. Understanding the justice needs gap in England and Wales, authored by the World Justice Project, draws together evidence spanning more than two decades to examine whether people can obtain advice, navigate support services, and achieve fair resolutions to everyday justice issues. It provides a comprehensive assessment of how effectively the civil justice system serves – or doesn’t serve – the public.
Looking across three periods of reform since the late 1990s – early civil procedure reform, legal aid reform, and court modernisation – the review examines differences in problem resolution within each period, highlighting inequalities in people’s chances of resolving their justice problems. It finds no consistent improvement in whether people’s legal needs were met, with persistent gaps in access to support and fair resolution remaining.
Review findings
Part of the Foundation’s Public right to justice programme, the review finds that while legal problems are common, millions of people are left without help or support to help resolve them. Using data from the Legal Service Board’s 2023 Individual Legal Needs Survey, the research shows that more than one-third (34%) of adults experienced a relatively serious legal problem in a four-year period, with housing, family, and accident or health-related disputes the most common.
- Among those who required advice or practical support, 38% did not receive it.
- Among people who needed advice, 54% of those with less knowledge and confidence to address legal problems were able to obtain it, compared with 68% of those with greater knowledge and confidence.
- When a case or process had ended, more than one-quarter (28%) said their underlying problem remained unresolved, while only 55% considered the process fair.
Concerningly, the system commands little trust, measured indirectly through questions about its performance and fairness, among those with experience of trying to resolve a legal problem. Less than a third of people trust the competence of justice actors and only one in ten believe the justice system would treat them fairly.
Recommendations
The review argues that addressing these challenges requires a greater focus on people’s experiences and outcomes, rather than measuring success primarily through case completion, cost or efficiency. It identifies recommendations to close the justice needs gap, improve access to support, and ensure that reforms work for everyone. They include:
- Designing services around people facing the greatest barriers to accessing justice
- Measuring whether people’s problems are resolved fairly, not simply the number of completed cases
- Better integrating advice services and dispute-resolution pathways
- Being transparent about how policy and funding decisions affect access to justice and who may be most affected by them
- Strengthening the evidence base through consistent data collection and improved use of administrative data
The review also highlights the wide-ranging impact justice problems can have on people’s lives. Psychological impacts were the most reported consequence, affecting 62% of respondents with a non-trivial justice problem. A more accessible and effective justice system could help resolve problems earlier and limit these wider harms.
Rob Street, Director of Justice at the Nuffield Foundation, said: “This review shows that trust in the justice system is very low among people who have experienced a legal problem – perhaps unsurprisingly, given the difficulties many face when trying to secure help. The system urgently needs to transform around people’s needs. This report clearly sets out the challenge before us to close the gap in access to justice and help more people obtain the advice they need to resolve their problems fairly and rebuild confidence in one of society’s most important institutions.”
Dr Daniela Barba, who led the research at the World Justice Project, added: “Drawing on decades of survey data from England and Wales and a review of justice reforms, we examined how people experience justice, including problems that never reach the courts and inequalities in problem resolution. Our research illustrates the value of creatively using existing evidence, while highlighting the need for more consistent data collection. Moreover, it underscores the importance of looking beyond average outcomes when designing reforms, particularly to consider who is most affected and whether reforms risk deepening inequalities.”











