Understanding the justice needs gap in England and Wales

Scroll down

This review looks at the gap between people’s justice needs and the solutions available to them, as well as the inequalities in people’s ability to access support and resolve their problems on fair terms.

Author
World Justice Project

Overview


Executive summary

This Review examines the justice system in England and Wales from the perspective of people experiencing everyday civil, family, and administrative justice problems. It applies a standardised framework of people-centred justice outcome indicators to three national legal needs surveys conducted by government and legal services institutions in 2004, 2014–15, and 2023 and brings this evidence together with more than two decades of reform and implementation evidence to examine whether people can obtain the support they need and resolve their justice problems on fair terms.

The review is separated into two complementary parts. Part A examines the full justice journey and how this relates to problem resolution, process fairness, and trust. Part B examines differences in people’s justice needs and resolution pathways across reform contexts since the late 1990s, particularly in relation to major reforms, policy changes, and wider pressures on the justice system.

The findings of this Review make a case for understanding both the gap between people’s justice needs and the solutions available to them, and the inequalities in people’s ability to access support and resolve their problems on fair terms.

  • Part A points to substantial and uneven gaps between people’s justice needs and their ability to obtain support, navigate processes, and reach fair resolution.
    • More than one-third of adults experienced a non-trivial justice problem.
    • However, substantial gaps remained in people’s ability to address those problems: nearly four in ten people who needed assistance and advice did not obtain it, three in ten who needed a dispute resolution mechanism did not access one, and nearly three in ten people whose process had concluded still had an unresolved problem; only just over half considered the concluded process fair.
    • These gaps were unevenly distributed. Legal capability was the clearest recurring divide across access, trust, process experience, fairness, and resolution, while disability, education, income, and experiencing several problems were associated with disadvantage at particular stages in the justice journey.
    • Income was not strongly associated with overall problem prevalence, but the types of problems that people faced differed by income. Considering problem severity, among people on lower incomes, more common problems are not necessarily less severe, a trend that has been observed among people on higher incomes.
    • The accumulation of problems was also associated with greater disadvantage: people experiencing several problems were more likely to report multiple hardships, to still have an ongoing process, and, where a process had concluded, to have an unresolved problem.
    • Different forms of support need to be considered together: after accounting for observed differences in people and their problems, estimated resolution was lowest among people who accessed a dispute resolution mechanism without also obtaining assistance and advice, and higher among those who obtained both.
  • Part B points to a recurring concern across three distinct reform contexts: the potential that changes in justice processes and support placed demands on people that were harder to meet when they had fewer resources, lower legal capability, or more demanding problems.
    • In Period 1, the 2004 Civil and Social Justice Survey (CSJS) evidence is interpreted in relation to early civil procedure reforms that increased what parties were expected to do before reaching court, while changes to publicly funded legal assistance altered what support was available and how it was provided. People facing problems more directly affected by these changes appeared less likely to reach resolution, with point estimates suggesting larger shortfalls among people on lower incomes and with lower educational attainment. The statistical evidence was imprecise but is interpreted alongside the broader body of evidence on reform and implementation.
    • In Period 2, the 2014–15 Legal Problem and Resolution Survey (LPRS) evidence is interpreted in relation to a reform context in which changes to court and tribunal administration occurred alongside reforms to legal-aid funding and, through the Legal Aid, Sentencing and Punishment of Offenders Act 2012 (LASPO), substantial restrictions to the scope and financial eligibility of civil legal aid. Problems more directly affected by the reforms were less likely to be resolved overall, and among people on lower incomes, substantially less likely. Estimates for education and legal capability pointed in the same direction, although they were less precise.
    • Under Modernisation, Period 3, the 2023 Individual Legal Needs Survey (ILNS) evidence is interpreted in relation to the continuing implementation of court and tribunal Modernisation, alongside COVID-19 and Brexit. There was little overall difference in resolution between routes more and less directly shaped by Modernisation. The survey did not show clear differences in this relationship by income or access to assistance and advice, although income does not directly capture digital or geographic barriers to access, and the assistance and advice measure combines diverse forms and quality of support. The estimates nevertheless suggested that people with lower legal capability and those facing more severe problems were less likely to resolve their problems through routes more directly shaped by Modernisation, although these differences were not statistically conclusive. Considered alongside the wider evidence on implementation, these patterns raise concerns about the challenges modernised processes may pose for people with greater support needs.
    • The survey relationships are associational (they do not imply causation) and are interpreted alongside the structured review of what the reforms changed, the mechanisms through which those changes could plausibly affect people’s justice journeys, and wider evidence on their implementation.

Across Parts A and B, disadvantage is most visible where demanding problems and justice processes meet limited resources, lower legal capability, and insufficient support. The findings therefore point to justice inequality as relational: disadvantage depends not only on people’s circumstances, but on how those circumstances interact with the demands of their problems and with the justice pathways available to address them. A people-centred assessment should look beyond whether services exist or processes conclude, to whether people in different circumstances can obtain and use the support they need to resolve their problems on fair terms.

Policy recommendations


1. Design for where disadvantage compounds

People face problems of different severity and complexity, with different resources and capabilities. Furthermore, disadvantage can compound before people reach a process, such as people in lower-income households being more exposed to problems involving welfare, debt, and housing insecurity. Reform should therefore consider not only average outcomes, but who is most exposed to the problems and services affected, and whether changes risk reinforcing existing inequalities, and should use this understanding to improve the design of justice processes so that they remain usable for people facing compounding disadvantage.

2. Manage scarcity-driven trade-offs explicitly

Reform can make processes simpler or more efficient while also changing what people themselves must understand, prepare, and manage. The Review does not argue that earlier levels of provision could have been sustained, or that outcomes would have been better without reform. Where resources are constrained, reform must ask how choices about funding and efficiency redistribute demands between institutions, services, and individuals; which people-centred outcomes and forms of support are protected; and who is expected to absorb the consequences.

3. Treat support and resolution routes as complementary

Where legal capability, problem severity, interconnected problems, or procedural demands make self-navigation difficult, services and resolution routes need visible entry points, coordinated and effective referrals, and sustained human support to be effective. Therefore, prioritise the frontline functions that help people identify, navigate, and resolve problems effectively, rather than assessing resource needs only through existing institutional structures.

4. Assess people’s outcomes as well as institutional performance

Measures of cost, timeliness, throughput, and process completion remain important, but they cannot show on their own whether people resolve the underlying problem or whether outcomes differ across people and problems. Reform should therefore be assessed not only by whether processes become faster, simpler, or more efficient, but also by whether people can obtain and use the support available to them and resolve their problems on fair terms.

5. Build better evidence for future reform

Despite substantial differences between successive surveys, considerable common analytical ground can be found. This approach can be leveraged in other contexts where data availability allows. Yet changes in measurement, survey design, and sample size continue to limit what can be examined consistently, particularly where multiple forms of disadvantage intersect. Future surveys require greater continuity in core measures, including severity, multiple problems, legal capability, access to services, resolution, duration, fairness, and hardship – as well as survey designs that support robust disaggregation and stronger links between legal needs, administrative, and service data. Together, these sources can provide a fuller picture of both people’s justice outcomes and the systems intended to respond to their needs.

Profile